Mar 16, 2019 even controversial youtube star logan paul recently expressed his desire to journey to the edge of the earth and released a mockumentary called the flat earth. Scholarship new and old tells us that, no, people living in the middle ages did not, as a rule, believe the world was flat. Michael marshall attended the uks annual gathering of people who share the unshakeable belief that the earth is flat. A view of earth from the iss on september 2, 2014 presumably photoshopped by evil nwo governments. History reveals that the church did not teach a flat earth. Sep 09, 2016 the response to the video has been hugesince it was first posted by a crimean man calling himself. I am focusing on these two as it is them upon whom the inventors of the flat earth myth focus.
A paper by jeffrey burton russell for the american scientific affiliation annual meeting august 4, 1997 at westmont college summarizing his book inventing the flat. I am referring to the false claim that a flat earth was popularly believed in, in general and was especially a christian bible based belief. Highlights of american history before 1850, for example, tells students about a conv. Columbus and the flat earth myth the american vision. One culture, i dont remember which, believed we were riding on a turtles back, sort of like discworld. Mar 27, 2017 the misconception people in the middle ages generally believed that the earth was flat and were persecuted by the church if they claimed it was a globe origin cartography one possible origin of the myth lies in medieval maps, especially the type called mappa mundi. Why, oh why, would anyone believe that the earth is flat. Did prescientific people really think that the earth was flat. Jun 29, 2017 does the bible teach that the earth is flat. The flat earth society is an active organization currently led by a virginian man named daniel shenton. Flat earth debunked nasa astronaut terry virts youtube. Liberals love to print the legend of the flat earth myth. A major promulgator of the flat earth myth was the 19thcentury american writer washington irving.
People often see them as primitive in their inaccuracy, but. During the early middle ages, virtually all scholars maintained the spherical viewpoint first expressed by the ancient greeks. Oct 10, 2011 in a 1991 book, inventing the flat earth, retired university of california professor jeffrey burton russell explains how the myth was perpetuated in the 1800s by writers including washington. Debunking the galileo myth dinesh dsouza many people have uncritically accepted the idea that there is a longstanding war between science and religion. The myth of the flat earth american scientific affiliation. The flat earth model is an archaic conception of earths shape as a plane or disk.
Even controversial youtube star logan paul recently expressed his desire to journey to the edge of the earth and released a mockumentary called. Football is the most popular sport and has the most impact worldwide, so creating a club dedicated to the flat earth movement is the best way to have a constant presence in the media. The flat earth myth a favorite myth of id critics michael newton keas february 6, 2019 intelligent design view at youtube. Contemporary historians have squashed this myth, with jeffrey russells book inventing the flat earth probably being the most detailed account of.
The earth is round, and other myths, debunked by the flat earth. Critics of intelligent design think theyre clever when they draw comparisons between id and belief in a flat earth. In a 1991 book, inventing the flat earth, retired university of california professor jeffrey burton russell explains how the myth was perpetuated in the 1800s by writers including washington. According to the atheist narrative, the medieval christians all believed that the earth was flat until the brilliant scientists showed up in the modern era to prove. Russell pinpoints the columbus flat error myth as invading our general culture in a series of books somewhere between 1860 and 1890. Aug 27, 2018 proof the earth is flat according to flat earthers there are hundreds of proofs the earth is flat. So in this section we will analyze the proofs they provide and try to ascertain if they actually prove the earth is flat or not. Draper invented the flat earth myth in an effort to attack biblical christianity. In the course of promoting my new book, how the catholic church built western civilization, i have made the point that major historians of science today no longer hold the simplistic position that religion has been nothing but an obstacle to science. Response to globebusters the earth still isnt flat. Created by alexander gleason in 1892 alongside his book is the. Since today is columbus day, i thought i would discuss a myth commonly associated with the man. The legend entered history when washington irving published his threevolume history of the life and voyages of christopher columbus 1828. The myth described in the article is a modern belief that wrongly claims that in the middle ages people commonly thought the earth was flat when they in fact did not.
The earliest documentation of a spherical earth comes from the ancient greeks 5th century bc. Modern critics are following his lead, as are liberal politicians who use the same rhetoric. The book is a delightful, provocative, and persuasive interpretation about a myth that has flitted in and out of popular history. Seven things that prove the earth is flat, according to. But the humans have failed to grasp the obvious, instead they gasp for air. Whilst its actually a myth that most people in the middle ages thought that the world was flat, and that columbus thought he was going to sail. The response to the video has been hugesince it was first posted by a crimean man calling himself. Flat earth supporters now plan an antarctica expedition to. The misconception people in the middle ages generally believed that the earth was flat and were persecuted by the church if they claimed it was a globe origin cartography one possible origin of the myth lies in medieval maps, especially the type called mappa mundi.
A paper by jeffrey burton russell for the american scientific affiliation annual meeting august 4, 1997 at westmont college summarizing his book inventing the flat earth. When looking out across the ocean, you can sort of see the. This denunciation culminated in a 1991 book, inventing the flat earth fig. Alan burdick writes about a growing community of people who reject the notion that the earth is round. The myth of the flat earth is a modern misconception that earth was believed to be flat rather than spherical by scholars and the educated during the middle ages in europe the earliest documentation of a spherical earth comes from the ancient greeks 5th century bc. The myth of the flat earth alearned learn somthing new. The bible is, from genesis to revelation, a flatearth book. Oct 12, 2015 since today is columbus day, i thought i would discuss a myth commonly associated with the man. The myth of the flat earth is a modern misconception that earth was believed to be flat rather than spherical by scholars and the educated during the middle. Apr 26, 2012 history reveals that the church did not teach a flat earth. Its a myth that christians ever propagated a flat earth. The myth of the flat earth is the modern misconception that the prevailing cosmological view during the middle ages saw the earth as flat, instead of spherical. The earth has yet again made a revolution about the sun. Busting a myth about columbus and a flat earth the.
May 25, 2011 draper, with a little help from washington irving, thus popularized the flat earth myth, the idea that prior to columbus there was a widespread, religiouslyinspired belief that the earth was flat. Like a fish out of water, they flounder about in fear of asphyxiation. Although hardly anyone in the church has ever believed the flat earth myth, incredibly, some people still do, wrote natalie wolchover in live science last year. We are born to unite the voices of millions of flat earth movement followers and all those people who are looking for answers. How the myth of the flatearth dogma started the religion. Debunking the flat earth myth the creation club a place. Why, oh why, would anyone believe that the earth is. The curious history of the international flat earth. Feb 05, 2019 the flat earth myth is debunked along with others in professor keass excellent new book, unbelievable. Flat earth spinning top earth and oceans by dazzathecameraman. Draper, with a little help from washington irving, thus popularized the flat earth myth, the idea that prior to columbus there was a widespread, religiouslyinspired belief that the earth was flat.
The flat earth myth is debunked along with others in professor keass excellent new book, unbelievable. Flatearthers have a wild new theory about forests the atlantic. May 02, 2018 michael marshall attended the uks annual gathering of people who share the unshakeable belief that the earth is flat. Find out the origins of our home planet and some of the key ingredients that help make this blue speck in space a unique global ecosystem. Known for his song airplanes, bob has shaken the boat lately with his vocal views on the flat earth. There are still people who believe the earth is flat. We need to know the truth about the flat earth myth. Debunking the galileo myth catholic education resource.
Flat earth also known as the flat earth myth, the flat earth theory, globe denial, flatearthism, less commonly platygeism, and intelligent geography for parodists of intelligent design is the pseudoscientific belief that the earth which the vast, vast majority of the population imagine in their heads as this big spherical thing or. Irving, best known for the legend of sleepy hollow and rip van winkle, used his fictionwriting skills to fabricate a. Jan 15, 2018 colorado is at the center of renewed flat earth movement, fueled by hundreds of videos on youtube claiming the world is a disk, space is fake, the moon landings phony and the curvature of the. Proof the earth is flat according to flat earthers there are hundreds of proofs the earth is flat. Columbus and modern historians praeger, 1991, jeffrey burton russell examines the origins, pervasiveness, and durability of this columbus myth and finds that it arose april 2007 591 take the lead. His work initiated mini movements one of them being the flat earth society, a modern group dedicated to promoting rowbothams ideas and trying to convince people that earth is indeed flat.
Although the flatearth myth was effectively debunked in 1991 by russells scholarly study, the flatearth myth is still used to claim that christianity has a long history of persecuting scientists. Watch our banned interview with david icke exclusively at business accelerator open now. Because people during the middle ages wrote about such things and left us a record of their thoughts. Youtube videos and spiffy websites espouse the conspiracy theory but is the movement doomed to once again fall flat over countless.
The earth is round, and other myths, debunked by the flat. Fake facts about christopher columbus and the flatearth myth. Earth not a globe, in which he affirmed that earth is flat. The history of an infamous idea hardcover august 5. Its so common that even here at howstuffworks weve been accused of endorsing flat earth theory because of the above stuff they dont want you to know video we produced in 2010. A word of warning and some advice for those who believe in various dogmas, myths and conspiracy theories, such as god, flat earth, aliens, ufos, bigfoot, the illuminati, new world order, etc.
The flat earth myth when looking out across the ocean, you can sort of see the curvature of the earth. The flat earth community did not like it one bit, and the channel globebusters decided to talk for three hours on their livestream about how stupid my video is, and how stupid i am. The myth of the flat earth is a modern misconception that earth was believed to be flat rather than spherical by scholars and the educated during the middle ages in europe. Exclusive interview with mark sargent jul 31, 2016 johndavis hello everyone, i am mark sargent and i am doing an exclusive video interview for john davis of the flat earth society, and he has a few question. In his fictional history of the life and voyages of christopher columbus 1828, irving wrote that flatearth churchmen had opposed columbus on the grounds that he would fall off the edge of the earth if he tried to sail across the atlantic. Uncle ed i think you have confused the more recent myth of the flat earth for the actual historical belief in a flat earth. Colorado is at the center of renewed flat earth movement, fueled by hundreds of videos on youtube claiming the world is a disk, space is fake, the moon landings phony and the curvature of the. Watch richard and calvin debunk the bible skeptics who misuse various bible passages to suggest that the bible says that the earth is flat.
If you subscribe to the idea of a flat earth, then youd believe that no such thing happened, because. I feel that this topic deserves its own thread since the flat earth myth strawman fallacy is a cornerstone of the darwinist fairy tale. How the myth of the flatearth dogma started the religionscience war. Inventing the flat earth by jeffrey burton russell praeger. Inventing the flat earth by jeffrey burton russell. This is a video response to a video called flat earth in 5 minutes, by odd tv, which makes several common claims made by flat earthers, but as i show, they.
In 1881, english writer samuel rowbotham published zetetic astronomy. In the video presentation, there is no water in the pool. Russell has written a scholarly, yet very readable, investigation into the flat earth myths background, origins, and consequences. For example, people who deny the science of climate change are like people who believed the earth was flat. Colorado is at the center of renewed flat earth movement, fueled by hundreds of videos on youtube claiming the world is a disk, space is fake. Planetary panoramas 360 degree nightsky timelapse by vincent brady, music by brandon mccoy.
Arguing about a flat earth has been going on for hundreds of years, each party always accusing the other of acting like a dumb kid. Russell has written a scholarly, yet very readable, investigation into the flat earth. Flat earth also known as the flat earth myth, the flat earth theory, globe denial, flatearthism, less commonly platygeism, and intelligent geography for parodists of intelligent design is the pseudoscientific belief that the earth which the vast, vast majority of the population imagine in their heads as this big spherical thing or oblate spheroidal thing, pedants is actually a flat. Its the myth that people in columbuss day thought the earth was flat.
1455 119 1051 590 948 841 964 520 1286 589 1339 755 765 355 843 629 718 262 183 1202 814 769 1464 1063 1449 410 83 406 1104 1237 581 805 1507 1224 1146 289 69 412 1371 918 576 997 740 307 975 290 746 1050 555 360